How To Determine Fault In A Car Accident
Colorado is an at-fault state. Therefore, in the event of a car accident, the driver who causes the accident is held liable for damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, and property damage.
Colorado drivers are required to carry minimum liability insurance to operate a vehicle ($25,000 per person for bodily injury, $50,000 per accident, and $15,000 property damage to another). This way, when a driver causes an accident, their insurance company will compensate the injured victim.
If you are involved in a car accident in Colorado Springs, you can recover damages by filing a claim with the at-fault driver’s insurance company. However, you must first establish liability to be compensated.
But how is fault determined in a car accident in Colorado Springs? Continue reading to learn more from our accident lawyers.
Negligence In Car Accident Claims
A driver must exercise reasonable care (a degree of care that a reasonably careful person would use under similar circumstances) to avoid causing harm to others. Failing to exercise reasonable care is considered negligent.
For example, when a driver speeds, runs the red light/stop sign, fails to yield, unsafely changes lanes, tailgates, or drives while distracted/drunk. Examples of common factors that contribute to accidents in Colorado Springs are careless driving, failing to yield, following too closely, lane violations, improper turning, and failing to stop at a signal.
Negligence is the foundation for determining fault in a car accident. To establish liability, you’ll need to prove the four elements of negligence, which are:
- Duty of care: The other driver owed you a legal obligation to act with reasonable care.
- Breach of duty of care: They failed to meet that duty of care by not driving safely.
- Causation: Their breach of duty of care directly caused your injuries. Your injury would not have happened “but for” the driver’s actions.
- Damages: The accident resulted in actual damages, including economic and non-economic damages.
You’ll need solid evidence to prove these four elements. This includes the police report, medical records, photos and videos of the scene, surveillance footage, and witness statements. These pieces of evidence provide crucial information about how the accident happened and the losses you suffered.
An Example Of A Car Accident
Two drivers (driver A and driver B) are following each other on the road, but driver B is not observing the safe following distance. They are following driver A too closely. When driver A comes to a section with heavy traffic, they slow down, but driver B is so close that they don’t have enough time and space to react safely. Since driver B cannot stop on time, they crash into driver A, causing a rear-end collision. This leads to injuries and property damage.
In this instance, driver B would be considered at fault for driving too closely.
Shared Fault Under Colorado Law
Under Colorado law, a person can only recover damages if their negligence was not as great as the negligence of the person against whom recovery is sought. Thus, your degree of fault must be 50% or less to receive compensation if you are injured. This is Colorado’s modified comparative negligence law.
Furthermore, if you are found to be partially at fault, your compensation will be reduced by your degree of fault. For instance, if you are found to be 20% at fault for the accident and your compensation is $100,000, you will receive $80,000.
Shared fault can happen when:
- A driver caused an accident after turning left illegally, but you were speeding straight through an intersection.
- A tailgater caused a rear-end collision, but your brake lights were broken.
- A driver hit you, but you were texting at the time of the accident.
- A distracted driver crashed into you, but you were speeding, and so forth.
Note that the other driver’s insurance company will typically assign you a percentage of fault, which, in most cases, is higher to reduce payout. You’ll need solid evidence to show you were not at fault whatsoever or that your percentage of fault was significantly lower than what the insurer is claiming. You’ll want to protect your ability to receive maximum compensation.
The Difference Between Criminal And Civil Fault In Colorado Springs Accidents
Criminal fault involves breaking the law, whereas civil fault is about being liable for injuries in a car accident. If a driver is distracted, causing an accident, they have civil liability. However, if the police officer investigating the scene issues the driver a citation, they will also have criminal fault.
A driver can have civil liability for a crash without receiving a traffic ticket or a criminal conviction. The responding law enforcement officer decides whether the driver should receive a ticket.
When a driver has both civil and criminal liability, they will need to go through two different proceedings. A private civil proceeding that involves negotiations to compensate the injured party and a public process initiated by the state aimed at proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt that the driver is guilty of the criminal offense, and, in turn, should face penalties.
Examples of violations that can result in a driver having both civil and criminal fault are driving under the influence or alcohol/other drugs, hit and run (leaving the scene), reckless driving, and vehicular homicide.
How Bachus & Schanker Can Help Colorado Springs Residents Injured In A Car Accident
We are local Colorado Springs car accident attorneys. We understand the local roads, which helps us identify factors that might have contributed to an accident. This knowledge is crucial when an at-fault party claims that factors outside their control, such as poor road conditions, caused the accident.
We also have extensive knowledge of local courts and procedures. We know the specific requirements for filing claims and the local rules of civil cases in Colorado Springs courts.
In addition, our law firm has established local relationships with other professionals, including medical experts, accident reconstructionists, and financial professionals, to help us obtain more information about cases.
We offer clients personalized, hands-on case management from start to finish. Your lawyer will take the time to understand your case to develop a tailored legal strategy that allows you to receive the compensation you deserve.
Our law firm also has a Victim’s Advocates team, which provides robust legal representation to uncover all the facts of your case, particularly when a case involves criminal actions.
This team handles evidence collection and communication with local law enforcement or prosecutors to hold all parties responsible. Most members of this team either worked for a police department or the judicial system, so they understand the civil and criminal justice system in depth.
Moreover, we have a proven track record in helping Colorado Springs residents maximize settlements and verdicts. We provide clients with clear guidance on civil claims and their legal options after a car accident, a quality that allows us to provide reliable representation that gets clients the maximum compensation.
Lastly, at Bachus & Schanker, we use a contingency fee arrangement. You will not pay unless we win your case, and we offer a free consultation to help clients understand their cases.
Explore Our Other Offices Across Colorado
Serving You 24/7 & Virtual Appointments Available
Related Car Accident Resources
#1 Amazon Best Seller in the Legal Industry
Attorney Kyle Bachus knows first-hand how difficult it can be to suddenly lose a loved one in an accident. It’s also devastating when you or a family member suffers severe injuries that forever change your lives. Kyle wrote this book as a resource from his personal experience for families who have suffered a traumatic loss.
A Spanish edition of the book is also available, offering the same support and guidance to Spanish-speaking families.

You Deserve Fair Compensation
Don’t let the insurance companies intimidate you into accepting less than you deserve. We’re ready to fight for you.
























